The Underground
Thursday, March 29th, 2007As Sean said before a few of us went to The Underground. Like Sean, my expectations were low simply because I’ve been there when people were dancing on the bar. I did however expect great food, because I had heard many excellent examples of their food.
If you read Sean’s post he calls me out a little bit, I’ll address that later, and I’ll start with what I had. Apparently the menu changes quite often, because the items on their site now are somewhat representative of what was on the menu that night. I wouldn’t let that hold you back though, if you like what you see, I’m sure you’ll find something very close.
I had the hanger steak with mustard sauce and fresh horseradish and the mac/cheese with prosciutto . Both were magnificent. The steak (that’s hanger not hangar) was grilled to a juicy medium with a fresh mustard sauce, then topped with fresh grated horseradish. I like horseradish, and you won’t find many places to take the time to use something fresh instead of something out of the bottle. I believe it was also served with some wilted greens. Definitely nothing against their presentation or taste, but honestly I forget some of the details, because my attention was focused on the side I’d ordered.
The mac/cheese used small elbow noodles and the sauce seemed like a mix of yellow and white cheddar cheeses. Besides just having a cheesy sauce, the chef mixed in prosciutto. The salty smoked flavor of the meat added a dimension I’d never tried. The entire dish was heated in the oven until a crispy (almost crust-like) layer was covering the top. I love mac/cheese and this proved to be one of my favorites.
Now, about the French fries. Yes, I believe the pomme frittes at Riviera will change your life. And I’ve said before, try those and even McDonalds fries will never be the same. With that being said, I’ll say that the fries at The Underground are spectacular. (See I’m not saying which is better, but I’m going to let you decide for yourself). These fries had a few things I loved besides being fried potatoes. First, I thought that traditional “hand cut” fries represented the best shape, I was wrong. These fries were long but they were about half the thickness of regular fries. So Sean is right, it was like you got a whole bowl of crunchy fries. Second, the garlic aioli was phenomenal. Catsup is so mundane give me this garlic infused dipping sauce any day.
–Matt